Review: My Birthday Song

January 20, 2018

Direction: Samir Soni

Producers: Sanjay Suri and Samir Soni 

Cast: Sanjay Suri, Nora Fatehi, Pitobash Tripathy


Hindi | Thriller | 95 Min | India | 2018



Sometimes the trailer does make more sense than the film itself. Don’t take me for being mean but that is just the case with Samir Soni’s debut film, My Birthday Song. Quite honestly, there is only so much thrill you can bear. For if in the name of thrills, all you get is a lot of confusion and frequent moments of ‘what’s-going-on-and-why-am-i-here-?’ kind of feeling throughout its duration of 1 hr 35 minutes you can be reasonably certain Soni’s effort isn’t going anywhere.


In fact, that is just the problem with the film. It doesn’t go anywhere. Even a thriller has to see movement of some sort – either forward or backward but if a plot just loops itself around itself – like Carr coiled around Mowgli, the man cub (of Jungle Book fame) with nothing but ‘Look at me, just loooook at me’ as audience you just want to get up and leave, except that call of duty allows you no relief!!


Samir Soni’s ‘thriller’ is nothing but adman Rajeev’s (Sanjay Suri) attempt to figure out why he is having nightmares by giving ghoulish looks to his psychiatrist in order to figure out his life’s mystery. He dreams of having accidentally murdered Sandy (played very woodenly by Nora Fatehi - a girl with whom he had a one night stand some years ago) on his 40th birthday night. She has gate crashed his party along with a close friend and after everyone’s gone home, they head for the bed – only to have Sandy crash into a piece of furniture and die on the spot.



If the film had progressed from that point on to some semblance of what their actual relationship is, Soni’s debut would have been bearable - instead it just spirals downwards into utter chaos. The film’s timeline gets chaotic for the plot moves backwards instead of forward. In other words, after the murder post birthday, Rajeev starts to relive his birthday from the morning prior – which means its endless birthday greetings from family, friends, relatives and colleagues and he knows in advance what the day will bring eventually. So he calls up his friend and warns him not to bring Sandy over to the party because he knows that she will die during the night. Instead, he goes to meet her at her hotel and ends up murdering her in the hotel room. Confused with a Capital ‘C’. Me too! For how can a woman turn up at a party late evening when she has died during the day?      


Perhaps Soni and his writer Vrushali Telang, his screenplay writer, can explain it better. All I can say is, the film’s certainly not worth your time. It certainly wasn’t mine. Suri, who has hitherto been part of real sensible cinema like My Brother Nikhil should have known better than to invest in this one as a producer and Soni should stick to his acting.





Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Please reload

Like our page on facebook to stay updated

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon

Related Posts

Please reload

October 18, 2018

The story by Akshat Ghildiyal, set in middle class Delhi’s Central Government quarters remains centre-stage while Priyamvada’s doting husband (Gajraj Rao); a cantankerous mother-in-law (Surekha Sikri); an incredulous son Nakul (Ayushmann Khuranna) and a younger son stu...

September 29, 2018

Yashraj Films gets 50 per cent marks – for trying. Actually, that’s unfair. The same marks should be divided between performances, concept and hard work. I am keeping back the balance 50 per cent and you will soon know why! Weaving dreams is great, being ambitious is f...

September 22, 2018

Saadat Hasan Manto was a writer far ahead of his times – at least 75 years ahead. But this measure is rather literal and I am saying this because the last seven decades are available to me in retrospection. For those who will remain sensitive to their times and the all...

September 8, 2018

The well-known actor Victor Banerjee’s latest outing ‘The Answer’ gives plenty of food for thought – especially since he essays the role of Paramhansa Yogananda - one of the world’s most well-known spiritual gurus of this century.

August 31, 2018

Here is a genuinely funny film. The wise cracks are novel, treatment different and the genre ‘horror comedy’ (as its maker likes to define it) definitely a new one. The humour is not forced and just about everything works for Amar Kaushik’s labour of love, Stree.

August 3, 2018

For a film which had the potential and possibly the vision of examining the very sensitive issue of ‘us’ and ‘them’ (read Hindus and Muslims) in a balanced manner, Anubhav Sinha’s Mulk tries but feebly. It does, however, make a very powerful case for those who want to...

July 28, 2018

Dhulia, Gill and Sheirgill are back. ‘Thanks Gods’? Well, depends on how much you love the franchise. Sheirgill as Saheb a.k.a Vijay Pratap Singh charms once again and Gill (read Mahie) as Biwi/Madhavi thickens the plot by plotting again. She is wiser, smarter and Oh-s...

July 20, 2018

Set in Udaipur, Dhadak tries to capture the local flavors in its use of the local dialect, Mewari. But it doesn’t capture caste divisions in society or mention honour as a byword. And because the undercurrents are missing, Dhadak ends up being a story about boy meeting...

July 15, 2018

Let’s talk about the problematic part first. One of the places where Shaad Ali fails to deliver in Soorma is when Sandeep Singh - portrayed exceptionally by Diljit Dosanjh - is in coma post a bullet that hit his spinal cord and grazed other vital organs.

June 29, 2018

When you walk into watch Sanju and watch it you should – you will see only Sanjay Dutt. That is right. Please don’t look for Ranbir Kapoor because he is not there. It is Sanjay Dutt all the way – and you will have to pinch yourself more than once to remember that it is...

Please reload

  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey Instagram Icon

© 2018 by Indian Film Institute